October 3, 2005. WiFi and Wimax are technologies for wireless data communication. A. WiFi was created for the needs of a single family's home. B. WiMax was created for the needs of an ISP company. Technologies are evolving towards convergence. By the end of t…
Article details
Published: 31 October 2005
October 3, 2005.
WiFi and Wimax are technologies
for wireless data communication.
A. WiFi was created for the needs
of a single family's home.
B. WiMax was created for the needs of an ISP company.
Technologies are evolving towards convergence.
By the end of the day, roaming between different technologies works and the Internet spreads everywhere. The names of the technologies will disappear from the consumer's view.
First, it should be noted that both standards are based on the currently popular orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing (OFDM) in the world of communications, use multiple pilot tones, and support modulation methods ranging from binary phase-shift keying (BPSK) to 64 QAM (quadrature amplitude modulation). Since such an introduction may seem a bit difficult for a non-engineer, let's try to explain the same thing more simply – data is transmitted basically the same way in both systems. Modulation methods in communication can be compared to vehicles moving on a highway (e.g., express buses). Then the radio channel is like a highway on which OFDM buses move back and forth.
The above is actually the only similarity between the two systems. Below we introduce the main differences between WiFi and WiMAX. While IEEE 802.11 defines 52 fixed 20 MHz subcarriers (i.e., a 52-seat OFDM bus), WiMAX may use up to 256 subcarriers with varying bandwidths (ranging from 1–28 MHz) (192 subcarriers are designated for data transmission; thus nearly four times larger and with adjustable seating for all passengers on the OFDM bus), both in unlicensed and licensed frequency spectrum portions. Early so-called “pre-WiMAX” test solutions use licensed spectrum and channel bandwidths of 3.5 and 7 MHz. The difference between unlicensed and licensed frequency spectrum parts is easy to demonstrate with a highway analogy – if an unlicensed frequency band were like a public highway, then with a licensed spectrum you get a private road along with the right to use it exactly when needed. WiFi systems operate exclusively in unlicensed frequency bands and therefore their use for backbone data communications is unjustifiably short-sighted. WiMAX, on the other hand, is suited for this purpose. And not just because it operates in licensed spectrum (plans also exist to develop unlicensed-band WiMAX), but primarily thanks to improvements in the communication technology itself.
The main innovations can be named as the following technical solutions.
Need a real-world follow-up?
If this article reflects an active hotspot, network, or security concern, the Wi-Fi emergency team can help right away.
WiMAX supports a subcarrier grouping function, which means that instead of transmitting data simultaneously on all 192 subcarriers, transmission can occur on a smaller number of subcarriers. In such a scenario, using the same power over fewer subcarriers achieves a longer coverage range in the system. Since WiMAX is also being developed for indoor use in equipment, power losses in signal transmission outside the building must be addressed. Because the customer premises equipment (CPE) power supply has limited power, the uplink and downlink energy balance is equalized and coverage distance increased by distributing power among fewer subcarriers. (In plain terms – passengers are transported as needed with smaller buses that use less fuel and can travel further.)
The greater number of subcarriers used by WiMAX gives it an advantage over IEEE 802.11, but also imposes more complex tasks on system designers since subcarrier separation is reduced – meaning that greater efforts are needed to eliminate phase noise and jitter. This leads to the need for higher-performance frequency synthesizers.
WiMAX also uses variable-length guard intervals to improve reliability under multi-path propagation conditions. The guard interval is a time reference measured from the start of a packet until the moment compensation for inter-symbol interference begins. When the transmission channel is free of interference, the guard interval length can be shortened, increasing channel throughput. Due to the larger number of subcarriers and variable-length guard intervals, WiMAX’s overall spectral efficiency is 15–40% higher compared to WiFi systems. For example, WiMAX achieves spectral efficiency values of 3.1–3.8 Mbit/s per MHz, whereas IEEE 802.11a/b/g does not exceed 2.7 Mbit/s/MHz (see table). Thus WiMAX requires significantly less radio frequency resource to transmit the same data volume, resulting in better interference resistance. This characteristic manifests to the user as more stable connections. Error resilience is also improved in WiMAX – the error vector magnitude (EVM) is set at about –25 dB in IEEE 802.11, necessary for a 10% packet error rate. In IEEE 802.16, the EVM value is improved to –31 dB, corresponding to a 1% packet error rate. Such a lower error rate allows WiMAX to achieve greater coverage. Greater coverage is also supported by the receiver's lower noise figure, with IEEE 802.16 imposing stricter limits. Specifically, IEEE 802.11's maximum noise figure is 10 dB, while IEEE 802.16 operates at about 7 dB. (OFDM buses are equipped with more complex yet more economical and nearly noiseless motors with higher efficiency.)
IEEE 802.11 supports only time division duplex (TDD), where transmission (Tx) and reception (Rx) occur on the same channel at different times. IEEE 802.16, however, offers greater flexibility, supporting both TDD and frequency division duplex (FDD), as well as hybrid frequency-division duplex (H-FDD). In FDD, transmission and reception occur on different frequencies; in H-FDD, they happen at different times and frequencies. This flexibility affects hardware cost and development time. For example, FDD systems are much more expensive because simultaneous transmit and receive operations require two completely independent radio modules. However, adopting FDD results in higher throughput since separate frequency bands are used for transmission and reception simultaneously.
Another important difference between WiMAX and IEEE 802.11 is the functions for measuring coverage distance and dynamically adjusting transmitter output power. IEEE 802.11 has fixed output power where radio modules transmit signals at constant power over time. WiMAX, however, determines proper timing and power settings using a coverage measurement procedure. This procedure ensures that signals received from each client device arrive at the base station with correct timing and power level. Therefore, IEEE 802.16 requires customer premises equipment to have a dynamic output power range of 50 dB. This requirement allows client devices closer to the base station to reduce output power while distant clients can operate at full power if needed. This function is very important because WiMAX supports transmission distances spanning kilometers, while a full-power client device near the base station could cause irreversible damage to the base station's radio module input stage.
In conclusion, WiMAX is expected to overcome all the well-known problems of WiFi networks (instability, short range, failures caused by interference). The next generation of wireless data communication has learned much from current WiFi to enable future systems to offer users what has long been desired – a data service that operates seamlessly and is always operational, unnoticed by the user.