November 14, 2002 We hereby convey the key principles of the WiFi philosophy on which the rapid development of wireless networks is based. This is the only known treatment on the subject! Mandatory reading for people who strive to unravel the essence of WiFi. The material requires good analytical thinking and an open mind for understanding. Challenge yourself: what did you understand? Wired (10/02) Vol. 10, No. 10, p. 116; Negroponte Nicholas MIT The wireless pond aka WiFi Nicholas Negroponte explains why Wi-Fi water lilies and frogs are shaping the future of telecommunications. image[pond.jpg] Media Lab founder Nicholas Negroponte predicts that wireless networks, or WiFi, will transform the future tangled mesh of centralized and ownership-protected communication systems into an open and mostly cheap/free service for users. Although telephone companies foresee the future of wireless data transmission in 3G technology, Negroponte claims that 3G is more suited for voice applications and its data rate in a couple of years will only be about 1 Mbps. Meanwhile, WiFi currently transmits data at 11 Mbps, and approximately 15 million people in the US alone already use it. Although WiFi reaches only about 300 meters without amplification, Negroponte argues that peer-to-peer technology allows creating a strong and free network capable of outperforming traditional internet connections from window to window. He emphasizes that the more individual nodes are connected equally, the better the network quality and capacity — contrary to traditional networks where more users mean reduced bandwidth and degraded connection. Moreover, technology is becoming cheaper and more functional, and specialized antennas can send signals over 20 km away, providing connections to geographically isolated settlements. Finally, traditional communication infrastructure must recognize the strength of the new network and relevant authorities should redistribute the spectrum so that it is collectively owned, rather than fragmented and thus less efficient as at present. EVERYTHING we have believed about telecommunications is changing. Large wired and wireless telephone service providers will be replaced by small operators, millions of whom will fit into the global broadband space. How will this happen? Read on. Over the past 30 years, three major changes have taken place in telecommunications. First: the advent of digital communication in the 1970s. Second: packet switching. Third: wireless communication. Each change brought fundamental innovation. With the first came multimedia, with the second permanent connections, with the third functional mobility. Along with declining regulation worldwide, these three generations of communication have given consumers many cheaper services. This especially applies to mobile phones, which have had a tremendous cultural impact globally (though least so in the US, which is another story). Voice-based 3G: too little, too late Compared to tremendous progress in other fields, today's wireless service providers are making very small, almost insignificant changes transitioning to the so-called third generation wireless. The arrival of 3G offers little because it lacks the characteristics of next-generation technology. It's still voice-centered communication at a time when data usage grows rapidly and 3G cannot remotely accommodate it all. WATER LILIES: THE REAL NEXT GENERATION Coincidentally, the computer industry has been working parallelly on an apparently unrelated field: wireless local area networks, aka WiFi. The initial idea was to get rid of cables and drilling holes into walls. Five years ago, I installed a wireless local area network at my home in Boston. At that time, I paid about $2,000 for the base station and $500 for each connected device. Today, the same items cost about $120 and $50 respectively—and prices continue falling. The result is explosive growth of this type of network—by modest estimates, 15 million people in the United States use it. Wi-Fi coverage extends beyond your home walls 802.11 systems—which are now available in many flavors, including 802.11b, commonly known as Wi-Fi—are not limited to home use. Depending on obstacles, “vanilla” Wi-Fi can reach over 300 meters. I live in a densely populated area, and about 100 neighbors can use my system. I don’t know how many actually use it (completely free), and frankly, I don’t care. I pay a fixed amount for the connection and am not jealous of others. Because on the same street, just beyond my system’s reach, another resident has set up their own Wi-Fi system, and so on. It is like a pond where first one water lily grows, then two, then four, then a whole cluster whose stems reach the Internet. (The water lily idea comes from European Commission President Romano Prodi’s technology adviser Alessandro Ovi.) Comparing system capacities: 3G can provide data transmission speeds of 1 megabit per second in the best case in a couple of years. Wi-Fi today offers standard solutions of 11 megabits, soon 54 megabits, and that is not the limit! 3G mobile phones appear in newspapers or at exhibitions, but WiFi computers have long been on sale and in many homes. Which system do you think will be more widely adopted? FROGS THAT JUMP ACROSS THE MESH NETWORK In the future, every Wi-Fi system will also act as a small router relying on its nearest neighbors. Messages jump through peer-to-peer links like frogs from water lily to water lily, making stems unnecessary. You have a broadband communication system built by people for people. Telecom companies know this but dismiss it, claiming the coverage is too small. But they are wrong. A broadband system built by people for people Three things make peer-to-peer architecture interesting. First, its emergence and spread are viral. (“Spreads like a Virus” is WiFi’s slogan.) Viral telecommunications is truly a new and fundamental phenomenon where everyone creates their own network and a whole forms by agreement. Given the decline of the telecom market and spending cuts, the new system is very attractive. Second, the network’s capacity grows as more nodes are added. Usually, increasing users means greater obstacles and worsened service quality. In this topology, adding nodes means better service. Third, electromagnetic radiation causes problems. Europe in particular is very aware of the unknown effects of electromagnetic "smog" on human health. In the US, there are occasional claims that phone handsets cause brain cancer. Whether these claims are proven or not, multi-hop network topology requires less energy because signals travel shorter distances. It can be assumed that lower energy consumption reduces risks. THE POND: TELECOMMUNICATIONS MARKET TAKES A NEW TURN Spectrum frequencies are today divided like real estate, with governments meticulously parceling it out. The price of this property has recently been insanely, completely unrealistically high at auctions. This is another reason everybody should be allowed to operate unimpeded and sovereignly. But new 'pond organization' methods are emerging, as more information fits into water lilies and frogs. Due to lower energy and money costs, wireless spectrum can be used much more efficiently. Especially interesting are areas left out for most to use license-free for anything. These relatively small, fragmented slices of bandwidth are essentially considered garbage. This unlicensed spectrum portion is used in wireless phones, garage door openers, microwave ovens, and various other harmless but unpredictable applications. Wi-Fi and recent experiments with spread spectrum and code division multiple access (CDMA) have brought people to think the spectrum allocation could be arranged differently. Its parts (or even the entire spectrum) could be viewed as large communal areas, not little plots. Instead of strict borders, appropriate behavior would apply. Instead of overexploitation of these shared areas, people should work, for example, considering energy usage limits. Well, it’s just like agreeing in an overcrowded cinema not to shout “fire!” Spectrum redistribution cannot happen overnight. Occupied electromagnetic zones are as hard to free as bulldozing a city district to build a park or cultural center. The impact of a new attitude would be quicker if we looked at ever higher frequencies and used them at shorter distances. The viral nature of license-free spectrum New thinking also impacts places where wireless coverage is extremely small—ironically in remote rural areas where water lilies grow and frogs jump. WiFi’s little secret is that with appropriate directional antennas its coverage can exceed 20 km. Imagine if a wireless network reached places where building conventional infrastructure is not economically feasible. In such cases, license-free communication would give a huge boost to human development, transforming everything from education to entertainment, from hospitals to office workplaces. That Splash would be heard everywhere!